3.25.01 Dana Milbank & Ellen Nakashima WashPost pA1
Bush's collection of "movement" conservatives, those identified with moral, religious or small-govt
causes, is wide-ranging: Otto Reich,
; Christian activist Kay Coles James,
slated to be solicitor general is Theodore B. Olson, who served on Richard Mellon
Scaife-funded American Spectator magazine's board & argued pivotal Supreme Court case
against affirmative action. Bush admin officials say conservatives' appt should not be surprising
because Bush is a conservative. They also say appts do not necessarily translate into right-wing
agenda. They point out that Bush continues to make his campaign themes, incl education, tax
cuts, and military & entitlement reform, top priorities. "The president is reaching out to
experienced individuals of highest integrity who share his commitment to a conservative agenda
with compassionate results," said Scott McClellan, Bush spokesman. Even moderate Republicans
say they are pleased with the lineup. "I am struck by the depth of the Bush bench," said Rep. Phil
English R-PA, noting that the appointments "don't run up any red flags." Still, Bush's appts surprise those who interpreted Bush's soothing campaign rhetoric to mean he was, if not a moderate, then a "new kind of Republican," as the campaign often said. Liberals believe such appts explain why Bush admin has taken actions on |
Walter Kansteiner Scowcroft resources rapist; FIPF
John Bolton State Dept
John Maisto NSC
John Negroponte UN
Otto Juan Reich State Dept
Bruce Chapman WHouse
Lorne Craner State Dept
Richard L. Huber NorteSur
John P. Walters Narc czar |
Growing up in Texas, becoming a businessman during the Reagan revolution, serving as a
governor of a southern state, Bush is the product of the changing times. "He's modernized the
Reagan model," said GOP strategist Scott Reed. But perhaps the most significant reason the new
Bush admin has eclipsed Reagan's in conservatism is the absence of moderate dissent. There is
no equivalent to Richard Darman, Reagan's former budget chief, a New England moderate who
had no patience for conservatives' ideas. "The Reagan administration was wracked by quarrels
between people who had strong ideological commitment to the president's campaign positions
who generally lacked expertise, and people who had expertise who, by and large, didn't respect
the president's campaign positions," said a philosophical conservative working for Bush. Now,
they're one and the same. There is a danger that the lack of competing views in the famously tight
WHouse could cause Bush's advisers to become stale & insular, but there is no concern
about that yet. "There isn't a lot of competition in the policy arena," a Bush official said with
satisfaction.
Bush seems to care about hiring more than Reagan did, accepting the idea that "personnel is
policy." The new president also seems determined to avoid the ways of his father, who
preferred businesslike managers. "They tended to be the moderates, the people who had gone to
the prestige prep schools and disproportionately tended to have Roman numerals behind their
names," said conservative Morton C. Blackwell, first term Reagan adviser & longtime GOP
National Committee member. Bush & aides appear to have concurred with the advice sent in
November by Hudson's Horowitz in memos to the transition team. He wrote that Bush should
"assign greater weight to intellectual capital & moral credibility than to management skills.
The close vote & contested election sharply increases the value of appointees able to
finesse the 'no mandate' pressures that will be placed on the governor."
Ideological conservatives haven't won every influential position in the Bush admin. SecState Colin
L. Powell & EPA Administrator Christine Todd Whitman have moderate credentials. And
Transportation Sec Norman Y. Mineta is a Democrat. If there is one weak link in the administration
for some movement conservatives, it is Treasury Sec Paul H. O'Neill, who has been advocating
reductions in carbon dioxide emissions for years and supported the imposition of an energy tax in
1993. Another disappointment for conservatives is Tom Scully, chosen to head Health Care
Finance Admin at Health & Human Services Dept. But social conservatives cheer Bush's pick
of Claude A. Allen for deputy secretary. As Virginia's health secretary, Allen, former press
secretary to Sen. Jesse Helms R-NC and a foe of right-to-die legislation, drew fire from health care
advocates who charged he would cut services to women & children.
Movement conservatives are generally delighted as many of their own take positions of power.
The recent hirings go far beyond the early naming of conservatives such as John D.
Ashcroft to head Justice Dept and Gale A. Norton to lead Interior Dept. In virtually
every instance where moderate candidates have vied with conservatives for key jobs, a
conservative has won. Ashcroft, for example, was selected over former Montana governor Marc
Racicot; & J. Steven Griles, a coal mining lobbyist, was selected over the more
moderate John Turner as the No. 2 at Interior. Conservatives are particularly pleased with Office of
Mgmnt & Budget. There, Jay Lefkowitz, former law partner of Kenneth W. Starr, is
chief counsel, joined by strong conservatives Sean O'Keefe & Director Mitchell E.
Daniels Jr. This gives conservatives sway over most regulatory decisions.
Justice Dept is another favorite location. Michael Chertoff, who advised Sen. Alfonse M.
D'Amato R-NY during Whitewater investigation, was named criminal division head. Larry
Thompson, Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas ally, is nominee for deputy atty general.
In WHouse, Timothy Goeglein, former religious conservative Gary Bauer and Sen. Dan
Coats R-IN aide, serves as liaison to conservative leaders. The speechwriting office features
writers from the Weekly Standard & National Review, and former advisers to Wm Bennett,
Jack Kemp & Quayle. WHouse counsel's office is staffed with former clerks to Justices
William H. Rehnquist, Antonin Scalia, Anthony M. Kennedy & Thomas, and members of the
conservative Federalist Society. The group has been successful beyond the counsel's office; it
counts as members Olson, Norton, Energy Secretary Spencer Abraham and his counsel,
Lee Liberman Otis, among others.
Several Bush nominees were endorsed by Heritage Foundation, leading conservative think tank
that has full-time staffer devoted to helping the administration with its appts, and who is in contact
with WHouse every day. Labor Sec Elaine L. Chao comes from Heritage, as does Cheney
adviser Nina Rees. Paula Dobriansky, conservative causes champion
recommended by Heritage, was nominated to undersecretary of state for global affairs. American
Enterprise Institute, with which VP & wife Lynne V. Cheney have been affiliated, also claims
John R. Bolton, nominated to be State Dept undersecretary for arms control & intl
security. Bolton is foe of intl organizations and is a man with whom, Helms has said, "I would want
to stand at Armageddon." The institute also can claim Lawrence B. Lindsey, Bush's top
economic adviser, and Diana Furchgott-Roth, staff chief to Council of Economic
Advisers.
Most of the sub-Cabinet & WHouse appointees are unknown to public and will remain
unknown throughout their terms. But they have extraordinary influence, and in some cases foes
fear them more than Cabinet officers. A case in point is John D. Graham, named to head
little-known Office of Information & Regulatory Affairs, which vets all significant or
controversial regulations. Graham is founder of Harvard Ctr for Risk Analysis, which is funded by
more than 100 large corporations & trade groups, incl Dow, 3M, Dupont, Monsanto, Exxon
& American Petroleum Institute. He is leading proponent of "comparative risk analysis" to
balance the need for regulation against risk of the event, and he was prominent in the 1995
regulatory reform battles. "John Graham has a long history of opposing even the most broadly
accepted public health protection measures, incl the measure to reduce drinking water
contamination," said Greg Wetstone, Natural Resources Defense Council spokesman. Graham's
nomination, Wetstone said, "is arguably the single sharpest stick in the eye of the public interest
community yet."
Bush LatinAm advisers' IranContra roles
Colin Powell, Sec.State
Sec.Defense military asst (known as "filter"). Autobio: Pentagon's "point man" for U.S. Contra
support. Key role funding Contras via
illegal arms sales to Iran.
John Maisto, Natl Security Council Adviser Inter-American affairs, hence cohort of Narc czar
J.P. Walters
Nicaragua ambassador during U.S. backed guerrilla war
against Sandinista govt.
John Negroponte, U.S. UN ambassador
FIPF
Honduras ambassador 1981-85
Oversaw military
buildup of country into anti-Sandinista contras' refuge
A 14-month investigation by The Sun, which included interviews with U.S. & Honduran
officials who could not have spoken freely at the time, shows that Negroponte learned from
numerous sources about the crimes of the unit called Battalion 316. The Honduran press
was full of reports about military abuses, including hundreds of newspaper stories in 1982 alone.
There were also direct pleas from Honduran officials to U.S. officials, including Negroponte. A
disgruntled former Honduran intelligence chief publicly denounced Battalion 316. Relatives of the
battalion's victims demonstrated in the streets and appealed to U.S. officials for intervention,
including once in an open letter to President Reagan's presidential envoy to Central America.
Rick Chidester, then jr political officer in Tegucigalpa U.S. Embassy, told The Sun that he
compiled substantial evidence of abuses by the Honduran military in 1982, but was ordered to
delete most of it from the annual human rights report prepared for the State Dept to deliver to
Congress. Those reports consistently misled Congress &
the public. "There are no political prisoners in Honduras,'' the State Dept asserted falsely in its
1983 human rights report.
Reports to Congress were crafted to convey Honduran govt & military as committed to
democratic ideals. It was important not to confront Congress with evidence that the military was
trampling on civil liberties & murdering dissidents. The truth could have triggered
congressional action under the Foreign Assistance Act, which generally prohibits military aid
to any govt that "engages in a consistent pattern of gross violations of internationally recognized
human rights.''
Fact vs. fiction
A comparison of the annual human rights reports prepared while Negroponte was ambassador
with the facts as they were then known shows that Congress was deliberately misled.
Negroponte replies
Negroponte, now U.S. ambassador to the Philippines, has declined repeated phone requests
& in writing since July for interviews about this report. However, on Thursday, after
publication of 3 parts of The Sun's series, he issued a written statement:
"Under my leadership, the embassy worked to promote the restoration and consolidation of
democracy in Honduras, including the advancement of human rights.'' He added, "At no time
during my tenure in Honduras did the embassy condone or conceal human rights violations. To the
contrary, the embassy & the State Dept cooperated with the Honduras govt to help remedy
recognized deficiencies in the administration of justice.''
Negroponte's arrival in Honduras coincided with the Reagan administration's decision to reduce
the emphasis that the Carter administration had put on rights issues in dealings with allies. The
new policy had been made clear to Negroponte's predecessor, Ambassador Binns, a Carter
appointee, after he repeatedly warned of human rights abuses by the Honduran military. In a June
1981 cable obtained by The Sun, Binns reported:
"I am deeply concerned at increasing evidence of officially sponsored/sanctioned assassinations
of political and criminal targets, which clearly indicate [Govt of Honduras] repression has built up a
head of steam much faster than we had anticipated.''
The reaction was swift & unexpected. Binns was summoned to Washington by Thomas O.
Enders, new assistant secretary of state for inter-American affairs. "I was told to stop human rights
reporting except in back channel. The fear was that if it came into the State Dept, it will leak,''
Binns recalled. "They wanted to keep assistance flowing. Increased violations by the Honduran
military would prejudice that.'' "Back channel'' messages are unofficial or informal communications,
often in code, sent outside the usual distribution system to restrict circulation of information.
Enders confirmed the 1981 meeting with Binns. "I told him that whereas human rights violations
had been the single most important focus of the previous administration's policy in Latin America,
the Reagan administration had broader interests,'' Enders said. "It believed that the most effective
way to overcome civil conflicts & human rights violations was to promote democratically
elected govts and that should be his point of focus.''
Ample evidence of abuses
There was nothing rare or vague about the evidence of military abuses that confronted
Negroponte from the time he took over as ambassador Nov. 1981. In 1982, his first full year in
Honduras, more than 300 articles in the local press included:
Evidence came from other sources.
Efrain Diaz Arrivillaga, then a delegate in the Honduran Congress and a voice of dissent in the
prevailing atmosphere of intimidation, said he spoke several times to Negroponte about the
military's human rights abuses. Diaz said that in meetings at the U.S. Embassy and at social
occasions, he rebuked Negroponte for the U.S. govt's refusal to take a stand against the
repression. The Honduran legislator said Negroponte reproached him for refusing to take a strong
stand against Communists who were trying to seize control of Honduras. "I remember Negroponte
told me, 'You and others, what you are proposing is to let communism take over this country
& over the region,' " Diaz said. "The most important thing to him was to win public support for
the presence of the U.S. military in Honduras,'' Diaz said. "Their [the U.S.] attitude was one of
tolerance and silence. They needed Honduras to loan its territory more than they were concerned
about innocent people being killed.''
Accusations against the military also came from former insiders. Aug. 1982, Col. Leonidas Torres
Arias, ousted chief of intelligence for the Honduran military, issued a public warning about
Battalion 316. In a news conference in Mexico City, he told reporters about "a death squad
operating in Honduras led by armed forces chief General Gustavo Alvarez.'' The story made
headlines in Mexico and across Central America. A reporter from the Honduran newspaper El
Tiempo asked Negroponte about the colonel's allegations. Said Negroponte in an article that
appeared 10.16.82 "Democracy is being consolidated in this country. The armed forces have
supported that process. It was the armed forces that turned over power to the civilian constitutional
leaders of Honduras. So, I have a lot of difficulty taking those kinds of accusations seriously.''
The evidence was also to be found in the streets of Tegucigalpa. Each week, hundreds marched
through the streets of the capital demanding the release of the disappeared. Sometimes they
marched past the U.S. Embassy, a hulking concrete complex on La Paz Avenue. The Committee
of the Relatives of the Disappeared in Honduras (COFADEH) turned to the U.S. govt for help.
6.13.83, COFADEH addressed an open letter to Richard Stone, President Reagan's special envoy
to Central America, complaining that the Honduran military was holding dissidents in clandestine
jails. "More than 40 people have been illegally arrested & tortured,'' the letter said. "Some
have never been heard from since their arrest.'' The letter was published in El Tiempo, one of the
largest newspapers in Honduras. The U.S. govt never responded to the committee's pleas. In an
interview, Stone said that he did not recall the letter.
Spurned at the embassy
Oct. 1983, members of COFADEH visited the U.S. Embassy to ask for help. They said they met
with Scott Thayer, a junior political officer assigned to monitor human rights. Among the relatives
who attended was Bertha Oliva, whose husband, Tomas Nativi, had been missing for more than 2
years. Also there was Zenaida Velasquez, whose brother, Manfredo, had been missing for more
than 2 years. The parents of Eduardo Lanza attended. Lanza, a medical student, had been a
prominent student leader when he was kidnapped by Battalion 316 Aug. 1982. The group told
Thayer that they had searched jails & hospitals across Honduras for their missing relatives,
that military officials only laughed at them and that judges were too afraid to help. They begged the
embassy to use its influence with Honduran officials to win their relatives' freedom.
Zenaida Velasquez remembers that Thayer listened politely, then dismissed their allegations. "He
said he knew Honduras had a democratic govt and [that] those kinds of practices were not going
on,'' Velasquez said. "They were such a bunch of liars it was disgusting.''
Thayer, now a political officer at the U.S. Embassy in Madrid, Spain, said that meeting with
Hondurans about human rights abuses "was part of my job. I recall having meetings like that, but I
can't recall that specific meeting.'' Oliva still fumes over the meeting. In an interview in
Tegucigalpa, she said that the embassy official acted as if they were fabricating the
disappearances of their relatives. "He was very cold, very cold,'' she said, pursing her lips. "Any
kindness was gone. He did not even smile at us.'' Roberto Becerra, father of the student Eduardo
Lanza, said he came away from the meeting with a hopeless feeling. "We felt like we were
screaming in the desert. No one heard us. No one would help us.''
In at least one case, Negroponte was confronted with evidence of abuse that he could not ignore,
arrest & torture in July 1982 of journalist Oscar Reyes and his wife, Gloria. Reyes, founder of
the journalism school at the National Autonomous University of Honduras, was openly sympathetic
to Marxist Sandinistas in Nicaragua and had written numerous newspaper columns criticizing the
Honduran military. The abduction of the Reyeses sparked newspaper stories & raucous
student protests. The Reyeses said they were locked in a secret cell for a week, and beaten
& tortured with electric shocks. At the U.S. Embassy, there was fear that if the story got to the
U.S. it might damage carefully assembled public support for the Central America program
operating out of Honduras. Cresencio S. Arcos, then the embassy press spokesman, alerted
Negroponte that the Honduran military had abducted the Reyeses.
"If they do this guy, then we're in trouble,'' Arcos warned. "We cannot let this guy get hurt.
It would be a disaster for our policy. "The ambassador did approach [General] Alvarez about this
to manifest his concern,'' Arcos said. The case clearly shows that Negroponte knew of the
Reyeses' abduction and that the ambassador acted in such cases when he felt compelled to do
so. Reyes & his wife were released from the clandestine jail after a week. They were taken
before a public court and sentenced to 6 months in prison. Two weeks before their sentences
ended, they were allowed to leave for the U.S. on condition that they keep quiet about the torture
they endured. That condition was laid down personally by Alvarez, said the Reyeses, who now live
in Vienna, Va.
The U.S. Embassy also kept quiet publicly about the Reyes case. It was not mentioned in the
human rights report for 1982, even though it was widely covered in the Honduran press and
illustrated the Honduran military's violation of human rights on several counts: illegal abduction,
secret incarceration, torture and suppression of press freedom. Instead, the 1982 report asserted:
"No incident of official interference with the media has been recorded for several years.''
Inside the embassy
Negroponte's aides at the embassy told The Sun that they knew about serious human rights
abuses by the Honduran military, and that the violence was a subject of constant discussion.
One of those aides was a junior political officer, Rick Chidester, who was assigned in 1982 to
gather information for the embassy's annual report on human rights, a task that usually fell to a
junior officer. Chidester, now 43 & a private businessman, said that while in Honduras, he
interviewed human rights advocates & journalists who provided him with information that the
Honduran military was illegally detaining, torturing & executing people. "I had allegations
about vans coming up to police cells and taking out people they [the Honduran military] didn't want
and shooting them,'' Chidester said. "`I had allegations that, as part of the interrogation
techniques, torture was being used.'' He said he included the allegations in his draft of the 1982
report.
A supervisor, who Chidester will not name, demanded proof, sworn testimony or photographs of
torture victims. Chidester said he was admonished for basing his report on rumors when he was
unable to produce such evidence. Chidester said he argued that while he had not interviewed
torture victims, the allegations came from too many credible sources to be ignored, and that the
reports were not supposed to be limited to provable facts. "While the State Dept is not an
investigative body, we're supposed to analyze political events & identify trends,'' Chidester
said. "Our analysis is valuable, even if based on opinion and not admissible as proof in a court of
law.'' His arguments failed.
By the time the report reached the U.S. Congress, the serious accusations against the Honduran
military had been removed. Allegations that remained were described as unsubstantiated or as
isolated abuses that had been dealt with swiftly by the Honduran government. Overall, the report
portrayed Honduras as an emerging democracy where the civilian govt & military respected
human rights. The report was such a misrepresentation of the facts that Chidester recalls joking
with others in the embassy: "What is this, the human rights report for Norway?''
An official explanation
While Negroponte has refused to be interviewed by The Sun, his boss at the time of his
appointment to Honduras described the priorities on human rights. Thomas Enders, the asst
secretary of state who told Negroponte's predecessor to stop reporting rights violations through
normal channels, said it was crucial to keep U.S. aid flowing to Honduras. "What we were
attempting to do was, on the one hand, to maintain our ability to act in Central America. That is,
our congressional authority to send economic & military aid, so we avoided direct public
confrontations against the military in El Salvador & Honduras,'' he said. "And at the same
time, privately we were spending an enormous amount of effort in order to change the way they
looked at how they behaved. There was endless jawboning.''
Instead of telling Congress what was going on in Central America, the Reagan administration
employed the State Dept human rights reports as instruments to advance policy objectives.
Consequently, the human rights reports differed sharply in tone, depending on whether the govt
was a friend or foe. The 1982 report on Nicaragua, where the U.S. was trying to topple the Marxist
Sandinista regime, made strong charges against that govt.
[ That govt brought literacy & universal health care to majority of population for
first time in national history while fighting for independence against U.S. mercenaries
]
A section titled "Respect for the Integrity of the Person, Including Freedom from Killing'' said:
"There is credible evidence that security forces have been responsible for the death of a number
of detained persons in 1982.'' In the same section of the Honduras report for 1982, the State
Department said: "Allegations that death squads have made their appearance in Honduras have
not been substantiated.'' Cresencio Arcos, press spokes-man in the U.S. Embassy in Tegucigalpa
from June 1980 to July 1985 and U.S. ambassador from Dec. 1989 to July 1993, explained the
difference:
"Invariably, the result in this process was to magnify your enemies' misdeeds and minimize
your friends' misdeeds,'' he said. Amb. Negroponte also made numerous public statements
praising Honduran military for supporting civilian govt and for respecting the rights of its people.
In a letter to NYTimes, published 9.12.82, he wrote: "Honduras' increasingly professional armed
forces are dedicated to defending the sovereignty and territorial integrity of the country, and they
are publicly committed to civilian constitutional rule.'' In Oct. 1982, he wrote to The Economist:
"Honduras' increasingly professional armed forces are fully supportive of this country's
constitutional system.'' That was the same year journalist Oscar Reyes and his wife were abducted
& tortured by the Honduran military for a week because of articles he had written.
8.12.83, the LATimes published a Negroponte column in which he acknowledged that there were
"credible allegations of some disappearances.'' However, he added: "There is no indication that
the infrequent human rights violations that do occur are part of deliberate govt policy."
[ CIA torture trainers instructed the military, not the civil govt. The torture was practice,
not policy. ]
"Indeed, disciplinary action has been taken against members of the police & military
(including officers) who have abused their authority.''
That year, in a case that gained notoriety, 24yr old leftist Ines Consuelo Murillo was held for more
than 11 weeks naked, beaten, suffocated, shocked, fondled & threatened with rape. To this
day, none of her torturers has been punished. Arcos said that Negroponte privately expressed
concerns about abuses to Honduran officials. "The ambassador did pressure the Hondurans. Not
publicly. Quietly,'' Arcos said. "We were concerned by the issue. Reports [of human rights abuses]
were increasing.'' Even years after he left Honduras, Negroponte would not publicly acknowledge
the crimes of kidnapping, torture and murder that were committed by the Honduran military.
During his Senate Foreign Relations Committee confirmation hearing as ambassador to Mexico in
1989, Negroponte was asked about Battalion 316 and its abuses. "I have never seen any
convincing substantiation that they were involved in death squad-type activities,'' he said.
Otto Juan Reich, Asst Sec.State W.Hem.Affairs
FIPF
First State Dept Office of Public Diplomacy for Latin America & Caribbean dir. 1983-86. Engaged in "prohibited, covert
propaganda activities" to promote Reagan policies toward Nicaragua. Maintained private network
of individuals & organizations coordinated with & sometimes directed by Col.Oliver North
as well as other NSC officials that raised & spent funds for influencing congressional votes
& U.S. domestic news media.
Right-wing Cuban American & former Venezuela ambassador. Dallas Morning News
Bush depending heavily on Cuban-Americans for key foreign policy advice. §
Ideology Triumphs Ctr for Intl Policy GAO
rpt
Senators John Kerry D-MA & Christopher Dodd D-CT are trying to squelch nomination of the
staunchly anti-Castro businessman & lobbyist by publicly criticizing Reich before he is
named. "The issue is not his conservative politics", Kerry said Friday. It was his central part in
"deeply divisive'' policies and domestic propaganda his office allegedly generated to support
Reagan administration C.Am policies in 1980s. Kerry & Dodd are influential members of the
evenly divided Senate Foreign Relations Committee which would handle the nomination if Pres.
GWBush selects Reich as asst sec of state for Western Hemisphere affairs. Marc Thiessen,
spokesman for committee chair Jesse Helms R-NC, dismissed the criticism, saying, "This is all
about Cuba'' & Reich's adamant opposition to Castro. If Reich gets the job, Thiessen said,
"he would probably be one of the most qualified people ever to hold the post.''
[ Qualified is no assurance of trustworthy. He aided violation of Boland Amendment
& abetted South Central L.A. crack; Freeway Rick=O.Blandon=O.North=O.Reich
]
Support for the former ambassador to Venezuela is also strong among fellow Cuban-Americans in
Congress. "Otto is a good fit with the president and is a good team player as well as a person who
has forward-thinking, innovative ideas on how to revamp U.S.-Latin American policy,'' Rep. Ileana
Ros-Lehtinen said Friday in phone interview from Miami. The Democrats' concerns over Reich
focus on his leadership of the State Dept's one-time Office of Public Diplomacy for Latin
America & Caribbean. The office, which Reich led from its inception in June 1983
until January 1986, was accused of illegal, covert domestic propaganda against
Nicaragua's leftist Sandinista govt and in favor of Contra rebels. Reich denied any wrongdoing.
The office "was one of the most open operations the State Dept had,'' he said in 1987. Reich did
not respond Friday to calls to his RMA Intl office in suburban Alexandria VA
Kerry, who led early investigations in the 1980s into whether the U.S. govt was secretly arming the
Contras, remains unconvinced. "Revelations that his office was the genesis of acts of propaganda
not just prohibited in this country, but which reflect a kind of carelessness about the truth, ought to
be of concern to any lawmaker,'' Kerry said.
[ Propaganda & carelessness with truth is a federal govt sine qua
non. Indict them all. ]
Eric Olson of liberal Washington Office on Latin America said Reich's background makes him "hugely controversial in Latin America'' and "not a good choice'' given Bush's desire to establish closer relations there. When Reich arrived in Caracas in 1986, he encountered official hostility because he was thought to be a right-wing extremist. Before he left in 1989, however, the country had given him its highest decoration. Critics also questioned Reich's lobbying work. He has lobbied for Bacardi-Martini, whose competitors can be sued for doing business in Cuba under Helms-Burton Act, which Reich played a role in writing. And his firm has lobbied to sell Lockheed-made F-16 fighters to Chile.
AIFLD has been disbanded by the current AFL-CIO leadership, largely because of its
compromised cold war mission. Otero, for instance, was identified by renegade CIA agent Philip
Agee as a onetime CIA operative. And the Doherty family is also linked to the agency. William
Doherty Sr., grandfather of WRAP director Lawrence, was a early labor leader associated with the
CIA in the 1940s. And Bill worked with the CIA in Latin America. Reich, too, worked with the CIA
on Central American during his tenure at OPD. But what can a professional anticommunist do
these days other than denounce Cuba? Apparently, there's prosweatshop work, where the three
adventurers now find themselves. If there's an any more precise explanation for Reich in the rag
trade, he's keeping it to himself. Actually he's keeping everything to himself these days-he's not
speaking to the press. Perhaps WRAP is no more than a corporate PR effort, but if that's so, why
is it staffed with cold war relics like Otero, Doherty and Reich? And, if the former "labor guys" are
running WRAP, why do they espouse an essentially unionbusting line? There may be as much
ideology here as profiteering, but we don't yet know.
In any case, Otto Reich shows that he is indeed not merely focused on preserving the Cuba
boycott. He is willing to link himself with other retrograde causes, including an implicitly antilabor,
antienvironment, prosweatshop organization. Just the man we need to run US hemisphere policy.
§UPPLEMENT
including
Sen. John McCain's CFR minder & NSC rep
If confirmed by Senate, Lorne W. Craner will step down as Intl Republican Institute president to
serve as asst secretary of State for democracy, human rights & labor. During 5yrs at IRI
helm, Craner has helped the "nonpartisan, democracy-building
organization" grow in terms of "achievement, innovative programming &
news coverage." Says Craner, 41: "We have programs in over 30 countries,
ranging from instructions on running campaigns to workshops on the
legislative process." He cites succesful election reform efforts in Central
Europe as one of the organization's major accomplishments. Before joining
the IRI, Craner worked under former National Security Advisor Brent
Scowcroft as director of Asian affairs. 1989-92 State Dept dep.asst sec. for legislative
affairs. Before that, foreign policy advisor to Sen. John McCain, R-AZ
Craner's late father, USAF Col. Robert Craner, was VietNam prisoner of war with McCain.
Around the Agencies
4.7.01 People §, National Journal
2.9.00 Christine Stone British Helsinki
HRts Group cryptoSerb agitprop?
Sen. McCain
one of his most significant foreign policy roles, chairman of
directors of Intl Republican Institute, founded in 1983 "to promote democracy, strengthen free
markets & the rule of law
a global campaign against tyranny & totalitarianism".
Since collapse of Communism, IRI has concentrated activity in former Soviet
bloc, and on elections in particular.
IRI, which had an office in the Albanian capital,
parroted all the accusations against Berisha's party. An IRI official in Washington called the hero of
the anti-Communist forces, Azem Haijdari, "a pig" in an interview in 1998 while supporting bona
fides of ex-Communist Socialist Party of Albania.
10.2.98 HIRC E.Asian & Pacific
Affairs subcomm re election monitoring
[ GOP Selection2K counting strategy from 1998 Cambodia election ]
7.6.97 John Murphy IRI LatinAm pgm officer Global Ctr for Democracy & Governance
[ putting Fox in charge with Mexico Cong. prelims using U.S. tax$ ]
1.24.94 Wm P. Hoar The New American
review The Men We Left Behind Henry Kissinger, Politics of Deceit & Tragic
Fate of POWs After Vietnam War, Mark Sauter & Jim Sanders National Press Books,
Bethesda, MD 1993
re father USAF pilot Robert Craner, Nam POW
The U.S. economy, which is a major motor of global growth, will also get a boost from the Bush administration's
$1.35 trillion tax cut and a series of interest rate reductions by the U.S. Federal Reserve. "The corrections that are
taking place in the U.S. economy are putting us on a footing that will put us to higher rates of real growth fairly
soon,'' O'Neill said. O'Neill declined to comment on whether Japan and Europe were doing enough to combat the
global slowdown, saying: "We're not here to throw rocks at each other.'' At the gathering, the top finance officials
from the United States, Japan, Germany, France, Britain, Italy and Canada were preparing the economics agenda
for a July 20-22 summit of G-8 leaders in the northern Italian city of Genoa.
Russian officials were also there for bilateral talks on the sidelines of the main event. ¹ The G-7 ministers generally agreed that the global economy had slowed down
more than expected, but remained confident that sound economic fundamentals and strong international
cooperation could fuel renewed expansion. Among measures recommended by the ministers to bolster growth was
a plan for economists to go through their countries region by region, identifying structural obstacles to growth there.
The ministers also recommended launching a new round of World Trade Organization negotiations to open more
borders to free trade, another action that could boost growth. To further shore up the economy, the ministers
agreed to strengthen the international financial system, liberalize access to capital markets and discuss
restructuring debt relief.
Japan's economic reform plans won high marks from the assembled ministers, with O'Neill winning a commitment from Japanese Finance Minister Masajuro Shiokawa that they will be in motion by this autumn. The Japanese economy shrank at an annual rate of 0.8% in the first quarter. The Japanese government has pledged to tackle a number of thorny issues, including measures to help banks write off huge sums of soured loans and steps to rein in wasteful public spending. The European Union was also optimistic, despite Germany & France, region's biggest economies, slashing growth forecasts in recent months. "The slowdown is sharper than we envisaged,'' EU Monetary Affairs Commissioner Pedro Solbes said. "But European growth figures are higher than those of the U.S. & Japan.'' EU economic growth is expected to come in between 2 and 2.5 percent this year, Solbes said, adding that various tax cut policies in some EU countries will help growth rates as well as stricter government spending. Earlier in the day, however, German Finance Minister Hans Eichel, stressed the euro zone's dependence on a quick U.S. rebound.
| 7.6.00 | Zimbabwe's Election | 2.22.00 | Fresh Start For Zimbabwe? |
| 5.6.98 | Clinton's African Experience | 3.16.98 | Clinton Goes to Africa |
| 12.2.97 | Kenyan Elections | 7.16.97 | Kenya's Political Future |
| 4.97 | Zaire | 11.15.96 | Eastern Zaire |
| 2.27.97 | African Response Force | 2.95 | Angola and Peacekeeping |
| 5.8.96 | S.African Cabinet Takes Different Shape | 1988 | S.Africa: Revolution or Reconciliation theology student thesis subject |
State Dept is focus of Dem. outrage for now. These nominations raise ''concerns about the real
commitment of the Bush administration to a bipartisan foreign policy,'' says Sen. John Kerry, D-
MA. ''Never before have so many ideological choices been made to execute key elements of what
a president argues will be a foreign policy beyond the ideological gridlock of the past.'' Although
Kerry & other Democrats will raise a stink about Bush's nominees, they aren't showing any
signs of trying to defeat the nominations, which Senate staffers privately say are virtually certain to
win confirmation. Interest groups that oppose Bolton, Reich and Negroponte say many senators
fear angering powerful Senate Foreign Relations Chairman Jesse Helms, R-N.C., avid supporter
of all three. Senate Dem. staffers also say that their bosses believe the slim chance of winning a
confirmation fight in an evenly divided Senate must be weighed carefully against the political risk
of opposing a nomination & losing. In the 50-50 Senate, VP Cheney has a tie-breaking
vote.
''No one is saying they won't oppose (Bolton),'' says John Isaacs, Council for a Livable World pres.
of group that advocates arms control. ''Clearly, senators are uncomfortable with Bolton and his
positions & his bkgd. The problem is that they're waiting for someone else to take the lead.''
WHouse officials say Bush stands behind his choices and is confident that they will be confirmed.
''If people have questions about their abilities or their qualifications, each of these nominees will
have ample opportunities to address those questions,'' NSC spokeswoman Mary Ellen
Countryman says. Democrats clearly have questions. Among them:
Critics of Bolton, currently vp at American Enterprise
Inst. home to right-wing luminaries such as Newt Gingrich, Richard Perle, Jeane Kirkpatrick
& Lynne Cheney, say abundant writings & speeches make him unfit to be
Undersecretary of State for Arms Control, Non-Proliferation & Intl Security, State Dept #3
& top arms-control official. Among the arms-control accords he has opposed is the
Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty, which President Clinton signed in 1996 but the Senate refused
to ratify. Bolton also has argued that Washington should recognize Taiwan, a move that would
reverse U.S. policy & infuriate China. ''It's like putting the wolf in the hen's house,'' says Don
Kraus, Campaign for U.N. Reform head [ Carl Nyberg
''This is a guy who, as best I can tell, has never seen a multilateral agreement that he liked.''
Helms, whose conservative foreign-policy views often rile Democrats, has called Bolton ''the kind
of man with whom I would want to stand at Armageddon.''
As 1984-89 asst atty general, Bolton crossed swords with both parties. He angered
Senate Democrats when he refused to provide requested documents during confirmation hearings
of two Supreme Court nominees. And Reagan WHouse slapped him down for criticizing
independent counsels investigating Reagan administration. Bolton also was president of the tax-
exempt National Policy Forum, GOP subsidiary, but left the post shortly before a 1997 cong. probe
into whether the group illegally took foreign donations during the 1996 election. No charges were
filed.
Reich, former U.S. Venezuela ambassador, headed covert Reagan admin pgm to
build public support for the Nicaraguan contras. Cong. watchdog agency GAO comptroller general,
concluded in 1987 that Reich's office ''engaged in prohibited, covert propaganda activities.'' Reich,
however, was never charged with any wrongdoing. The Cuban native, who emigrated to the USA
when he was 15, has strong backing in Florida among Cuban-American leaders, who were
energetic supporters of Bush's presidential bid last year.
Critics of Negroponte, career diplomat & close friend of SecState Colin
Powell, contend he turned a blind eye to human rights abuses by Honduran military while he was
ambassador. But Senate aides say Negroponte's confirmation is virtually assured because of his
friendship with Powell and Senate's approval of his more recent stints as ambassador to Mexico
and the Philippines.
| presented by § |
OCIAL JUSTICE |